GOLFNOTEBOOK
COURSEOBSERVER
BIZOBSERVER
PEOPLE
USERFORUMS
GOLFSTATS
AMERICANGOLFER
 
ADVERTISMENT

FEATURES FROM THE GALLERY


John Huggan

John Huggan is the European correspondent for both Golf Digest and Golf World. He is also the golf columnist for Scotland on Sunday. He lives in Dunbar, Scotland, where he hits many very bad half-wedge shots from around 75-yards or so.

Today Huggan chats it up about Scotland's best woman golfer, Catriona Matthew and how much her life has changed since the last time she played on the LPGA Tour.


- GolfObserver editors

Europeans are just one for 33 at the Players
May 9, 2007
By John Huggan

Amidst all the increasingly tedious wailing and gnashing of teeth that has accompanied the so-far almost eight years of European failure in major championships since Scotland's Paul Lawrie did


Photo: ©David Cannon/Allsport
Sandy Lyle is the only European to win the Players at that was 20 years ago.
the business at Carnoustie back in 1999, another aspect of golf at the (almost) highest level has gone relatively unnoticed. With the notable exception of Sandy Lyle two decades ago, men from the old world haven't been winning The Players Championship, what some of the more uninformed and deluded amongst us like to refer to as the game's 'fifth major,' either.


Oh, there have been the occasional close-run things, most memorably Colin Montgomerie's brace of runner-up finishes in 1995 and '96, a feat duplicated by Padraig Harrington in 2003 and 04. Other European notables like Nick Faldo, Bernhard Langer and, most recently, Henrik Stenson, have posted top-three finishes over the years, but mostly, the PGA Tour's flagship event has been dominated by the US Navy, with only the occasional foreign interloper interrupting the home fleet's almost perennial success.

Indeed, the first 13 editions of what started as the Tournament Players Championship, morphed into The Players Championship and is now apparently just The Players, were won by nephews of Uncle Sam, since when four Antipodeans - Steve Elkington, Greg Norman, Craig Perks and Adam Scott - have joined Zimbabwe's Nick Price and this week's defending champion Stephen Ames of Trinidad & Tobago as overseas winners of golf's fifth most important event.

Best European Tour finishes at the Players:
Year Player Finish / Strokes back of winner
1987 Sandy Lyle Winner / in playoff
1992 Nick Faldo T2nd / 4 back
1993 Bernhard Langer 2nd / 5 back
1995 Bernhard Langer 2nd / 1 back
1996 Colin Montgomerie T2nd / 4 back
2003 Padraig Harrington T2nd / 6 back
2004 Padraig Harrington 2nd / 1 back

But, post-Sandy, no more Europeans. Not one. None. Zero. Nada. Zip. Nothing. A Scot winning the US Amateur Championship is seemingly more likely. Oh. . .

Even when the very best Europeans were the very best players in the world back in the 1980s and early 1990s, the rest of the so-called 'Big-Five' weren't getting the job done around what was then viewed as Pete Dye's demonic creation. Not Seve Ballesteros. Not Ian Woosnam. Not Langer. And not Faldo.

At least in Faldo's case, lack of real interest was definitely a factor. At a time when the lanky Englishman was the man to beat in almost every Grand Slam event, your correspondent came across the six-time major champion on the 16th tee in the final round of a Players Championship. As I recall, Faldo was on the edge of contention but was unlikely to win, even if the water-strewn final holes at the TPC of Sawgrass did happen to throw up one of the many wild and wacky swings seen there over the years. But he was up there somewhere.


Photo: © David Cannon /Allsport
Nick Faldo played in 21 Players and finished in the Top-ten twice, T2nd in 1992 and 5th in 1994.

Anyway, the point of the story is this: in the last round of what was already one of the game's biggest and most prestigious events, the world's best player was working on his method. Driving from that 16th tee, Faldo pointedly kept his left heel off the ground at address. He was performing a swing drill rather than focusing on the job at hand!

That the Masters Tournament was taking place two weeks later was no coincidence, of course. Notoriously, Faldo cared only for golf's four biggest events and little for anything else. As far as he was concerned, number five might as well have been number 1,000. For Faldo, the Players represented simply a warm-up event for something bigger.

For the rest, other factors have come into play, at least in the Player's early days. The course, for example. Until its latest makeover, Sawgrass has been the quintessential American venue. Long rough bordered the fairways and greens. Water hazards were and are seemingly everywhere. The greens were ultra-fast. In other words, conditions all but impossible to reproduce exactly across the Atlantic, especially if you throw in a bit of humidity. Europe just isn't like Florida.

Still, in recent times such a foreign environment shouldn't have been quite so foreign to the foreign contingent from Europe. With more and more of them spending more and more of their time salivating over the ridiculously rich PGA Tour pickings available since the coming of Tiger, Europe's best are surely becoming more and more familiar with what is known across the pond as 'American golf,' as if no other types of courses exist in the US. So not feeling at home is no longer a valid reason for failure.

Nor is the fact that, until this year, the Players has been played in March. Yes, the 'too early in the season for us' excuse had some merit back in the 1980s, but it is no longer valid. Like their US counterparts, the best Europeans now play a global schedule that lasts almost 12 months of every year.


Photo: © Stan Badz/WireImage
The 17th hole with all of the people around it can be a scary experience for a player.
Then again, now that I come to think of it, maybe the Europeans do have a problem taking seriously at least one aspect of the Sawgrass course. If, like me, they see the island green at the penultimate hole as nothing more than a mindless contrivance that has no place in any event claiming to be anything other than a circus, then perhaps they have a similarly hard time rating the whole week as anything other than just another opportunity to trouser a large check. After all, another tournnament just like it will be along next week.

So, if the Players is ever to attain its much-coveted major status, one of the things that must change is the 17th hole. As my Aussie friend, former European Tour player and now successful course architect Mike Clayton says, "It's American golf (there's that phrase again). It's entertainment. The fans want to see a car wreck and that's what it is. (Fellow course architect) Tom Doak called it 'the germ that started the plague.' It's been copied too often, fortunately not in Australia, but mainly in Asia, where they think that everything American is great."


Photo: © Richard Heathcote/Getty Images
Tiger Woods hitting his 2nd shot into 18 with the new clubhouse in the background.

This year - apart from the much-changed course and the sparkly-new clubhouse (how do you spell 'gaudy' and 'tasteless?') - the Players is going to be different in at least one other aspect. The foreign press contingent, especially that from the United Kingdom, is going to be much depleted. Deprived of the opportunity to work on Masters-preview pieces, the British journos are staying away in droves. Only three are making the trip to Sawgrass.

Now, this may seem trivial, but it has implications in two important areas. In the early days of the Masters - long before it was recognized as a major - Bobby Jones and Clifford Roberts made a point of inviting the leading British pressmen, Henry Longhurst, Pat Ward-Thomas, Leonard Crawley, to Augusta on an annual basis. Consciously or not, they knew that international coverage of their 'toonamint' was vital if it was to transcend its rivals and become one of the most important stops on the schedule.

Television is also important in that respect. The Masters has always been shown on the BBC, on a channel open and free to all. This year, the Players will only be available in Britain on something called Setanta Sports, a fledgling fee-paying satellite channel with, as yet, only a miniscule audience. No one will be watching - or, by extension, caring.

For the Players and PGA Tour commissioner Tim Finchem not to be learning the lessons of history seems strange. Finchem's apparent indifference only adds to the 'just another big money event' impression that will make the tournament less important outside the confines of the US and, in turn, contribute to the death of any major aspirations.

Secondly - and this may be overestimating the effect of the media more than a little - lack of coverage at home may subconsciously affect the extent to which the European players yearn for a Players win. If no one else sees it as worth making an effort for, why should they?

The mind goes back to dear old Sandy in the immediate aftermath of his victory in '87. Asked what the difference was between this latest win and his Open Championship triumph two years earlier at Royal St. Georges, the guileless and loveable Scot replied, "oh, about 125 years."

So there you have it. Europeans can't be bothered winning the Players because they really don't think it's that big a deal. Sorry, Tim.


ADVERTISMENT
ADVERTISMENT


Real Golf Radio Classics of golf

Copyright © 2008 GolfObserver.com, All Rights Reserved